Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:love:
 
©2009 ~Anischenko
:iconanischenko:

Artist's Comments

I'd like to know what to do about this one. I'm trying some photoshop stuff and I think this is what I'm looking for in my photo's colors. Now, I think I may have overdone it, and I'd like to know if this is... acceptable?

Straight up;

1.- I'd like you to critique the colors on this one compared to the other. Are they too exagerated? Maybe I darkened them too much? Any other comment on this would be appreciated.

2.- Is this level of retouching too much? Maybe it's a personal decition, but I'd like you to tell me as well.

See ya

This is the original image, nothing done on it.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 4 4 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconeanur0:
Mmmmh.. Actualy, I would turn color in a green field, like a post-apocaliptical pic'... I like this lvl too, you did it right.

Seriously, nice shot!

--
FLICKR' IT!
:iconanischenko:
Thanks! Nice suggestion. I'll try out more stuff whenever I can. Glad to know my retouching is not so bad!

--
It's your fauvorite south american Indiana Jones
:iconeanur0:
Tell me if you're going to do some change on your pic'!

--
FLICKR' IT!
:iconanischenko:
You like it? Thanks! You can always reply saying what you like/don't like/would like to improve from this photo!

--
It's your fauvorite south american Indiana Jones
:iconraishuu:
from :icongimmefeedback:

I think it really depends on what mood you want to depict. The original image is much brighter and happier in a way while the retouched version looks more deserted and foreboding to me. I think either is fine, though maybe I would light up the sign just a little bit on the second version.
Sorry if I can't be of any more help, but I really like both :D

--
Pencil Portrait Comissions? Click me!
Want to meet German Deviants? ~GetTogether
Helpful comments and critiques? #GimmeFeedback
Bored? FreeRice.com
:icona-sad-pandas-poptart:
It looks fine to me, maybe lighten it up just a bit?
:iconthorthunder3:
from :icongimmefeedback:
I think that mood you want to depict would decide which version is better (like what Raischuu said). This one is much more dramatic and bold compared to the other one, if anything, try brightening the signs a little.

--
"I would say that it is not the medium, but the quality of perception and expression that makes the significance of art, but what does a cartoonist know? " Bill Watterson
[link]

Details

June 30
1.5 MB
185 KB
1024×592

Statistics

20
4 [who?]
160 (0 today)
7 (0 today)

Camera Data

Canon
Canon PowerShot A720 IS
1/636 second
F/5.0
7 mm
100
Apr 24, 2009, 2:20:53 PM

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map